Holiday pre-orders

Life is too short for Ordinary Cookies.

Order your holiday boxes directly from this page. Local pickup.

Pre-order deadline: October 30

Holiday boxes

Beautifully wrapped and ready for gifting.

Build Your Holiday Box: 6 Build Your Holiday Box: 6
Build Your Holiday Box: 6
$30.00

Beautifully wrapped. Choose 5 flavors; includes a Merry Christmas / Happy Holidays sugar cookie.

Build Your Holiday Box: 12 Build Your Holiday Box: 12
Build Your Holiday Box: 12
$55.00

Beautifully wrapped. Choose 11 flavors; includes a Merry Christmas / Happy Holidays sugar cookie.

Holiday Sugar Cookie Set: 6 Holiday Sugar Cookie Set: 6
Holiday Sugar Cookie Set: 6
$30.00

6 sugar cookies, beautifully packaged for gifting.

Holiday Sugar Cookie Set: 12 Holiday Sugar Cookie Set: 12
Holiday Sugar Cookie Set: 12
$50.00

12 sugar cookies, beautifully packaged for gifting.


Christmas Eve Box Christmas Eve Box
Christmas Eve Box
$40.00

Gingerbread, spumoni, sugar cookies, NYC minis and candied pecan snowballs.

Box of 12 Minis Box of 12 Minis
Box of 12 Minis
$24.00

Chocolate chip, almond croissant, cranberry pistachio white chocolate and peanut butter chocolate.

Gluten Free Box Gluten Free Box
Gluten Free Box
$35.00

6 cookies: NYC dark chocolate, NYC raspberry white chocolate, NYC birthday cake and 3 sugar cookies.


Business gifting

Logo sugar cookies, heat sealed with ribbon. Minimum order 12.

Bucket of Chocolate Chip Bucket of Chocolate Chip
Bucket of Chocolate Chip
$10.00

A small gift bucket of our chocolate chip cookies.


Bucket of Snowballs Bucket of Snowballs
Bucket of Snowballs
$10.00

A small gift bucket of candied pecan snowballs.


Bucket of Mini Sugar Cookies Bucket of Mini Sugar Cookies
Bucket of Mini Sugar Cookies
$10.00

A small gift bucket of mini sugar cookies.


Small gifts

$10 each

Logo Sugar Cookies Logo Sugar Cookies
Logo Sugar Cookies
$4.25

Your logo on a sugar cookie. Heat sealed and includes ribbon. $4.25 each, minimum 12.