Pick your cookies
Life is too short for Ordinary Cookies.
Build your box, then check out with your favorite card.
Local delivery 24–48 hours.
Build your own box
Pick your own flavors — mix and match.
Build a 6-Box
Choose any 6 flavors
Build a 12-Box
Choose any 12 flavors
Old chocolate flavor meets bakery-style perfection. Our thick New York Style Dark Chocolate Chip Cookie is packed with premium dark chocolate chips, featuring crisp edges and a soft, gooey center for a rich and unforgettable cookie experience.
Our New York Style Milk Chocolate Chip Pecan Cookie is thick, buttery, and loaded with creamy milk chocolate chips and roasted pecans. With crisp golden edges, a soft center, and the perfect balance of sweet chocolate and nutty crunch, this oversized cookie delivers a rich, satisfying bite every time.
Sweet, citrusy, and irresistibly gooey. Our NYC Lemon Meringue Cookie is packed with fresh lemon zest, creamy white chocolate chips, and crunchy vanilla meringue pieces, creating the perfect balance of bright lemon flavor and bakery-style indulgence.
A perfect balance of sweet and tart. Our NYC Raspberry White Chocolate Cookie is packed with white chocolate chips, caramelized white chocolate chunks, and freeze-dried raspberries for a rich, fruity, and irresistibly gooey bakery-style treat.
Buttery, nutty, and irresistibly indulgent. Our NYC Almond Croissant Cookie is filled with sweet almond cream, topped with sliced almonds, and baked into a thick, bakery-style cookie inspired by the classic French pastry.
Our NYC Peanut Butter Cookie is a thick, oversized New York-style cookie crafted with creamy peanut butter and loaded with peanut butter chips for double the flavor. Baked to golden perfection, it features crisp edges, a soft, melt-in-your-mouth center, and a perfectly balanced sweetness that lets the roasted peanut flavor shine.
an't choose just one flavor? The NYC Mini Sampler Box lets you experience our most-loved cookies in perfectly sized mini form. Each mini cookie is baked fresh with premium ingredients and packed with the same thick, soft centers and rich flavor that make our full-size cookies a customer favorite.
Includes an Assortment of Our Best Sellers:
Perfect for gifting, parties, office treats, dessert tables, or when you simply want to try them all.
Every day deserves a celebration with our signature NYC Birthday Cake Cookie. This thick, bakery-style cookie is loaded with creamy white chocolate chips, rich caramelized white chocolate chunks, and an explosion of colorful rainbow sprinkles in every bite.
The Ninja starts with a rich black cocoa cookie, hiding a soft chocolate chip cookie at its core. Break it open to reveal a molten chocolate caramel center that flows with every warm bite.
With crisp edges, a gooey center, and layers of deep cocoa, melty chocolate, and silky caramel, every bite is pure indulgence. Mysterious on the outside, unforgettable on the inside—just like a true ninja.
A campfire classic with a Ninja Bake twist. This oversized New York Style chocolate chip cookie is stuffed with a gooey marshmallow center, then baked on top of a buttery graham cracker and a full Reese's Peanut Butter Cup.
handcrafted fresh in small batches and beautifully packaged in our signature Ninja Bake Cookies gift box. Each oversized cookie is thick, soft in the center, perfectly crisp around the edges, and loaded with premium ingredients for an unforgettable bite. Includes:
6 oversized New York Style gourmet cookies
Freshly baked to order
Beautifully packaged in our signature Ninja Bake Cookies box
Perfect for gifting, sharing, or indulging yourself
Warning: Once you open the box, sharing becomes optional. Go to custom orders to pick flavors. Or Ninja can pick a variety.
The 12 Count New York Style Cookie Box is packed with a full dozen of our handcrafted, oversized gourmet cookies—freshly baked, generously loaded with premium ingredients, and beautifully presented in our signature Ninja Bake Cookies box. Includes:
12 oversized New York Style gourmet cookies
Freshly baked to order using premium ingredients
Beautifully packaged in our signature Ninja Bake Cookies gift box
Ideal for gifting, parties, corporate events, and sharing with family and friends
Ninja Bake Promise: Every box is handcrafted with care, baked fresh, and delivered with the quality and flavor that keeps our customers coming back for more. Because life is better with cookies. Go to CUSTOM ORDERS to pick flavors. Or Ninja can pick a variety.
Our take on New York City's most iconic cookie starts with a thick, buttery, cake-like vanilla base baked until perfectly soft. It's finished with the classic half silky chocolate icing and half smooth vanilla icing for the unmistakable look and flavor New Yorkers love.
Made fresh from scratch with premium ingredients, this bakery classic is simple, nostalgic, and timeless. One bite, and you'll see why it's been a New York favorite for over a century.
Our New York Style Cookies & Cream Cookie is thick, buttery, and packed with Oreo cookie chunks and creamy white chocolate. Stuffed with a rich cookies & cream cheesecake center, topped with a white chocolate drizzle, crushed Oreos, and a mini Oreo for the ultimate cookies & cream experience.